Customer Service - Butler Insurance

Butler Insurance with Dogs

At Butler Insurance, we strive to deliver the high-quality customer service that we would expect ourselves.

Our Door is Always Open

We’re available in person, on the phone, and by email. After business hours we check our voicemail service regularly to ensure you are taken care of in the case of an emergency. Feel free to contact us should you ever have questions about your bill, coverage, or have a “what if” question due to a possible change in your life such as adding another driver, buying a new car, starting a business, purchasing a recreational vehicle or an addition to the family. Whatever the case may be, we can help you determine what coverage you’ll need.

When You Need Us

Should you ever have a loss, contact our office as soon as possible. We’ll be there to help you through the claims process. Whether it is a minor event, such as a cracked windshield, or a major event like a house fire, we will help you through the process of repairing or replacing your covered loss. We are committed to your happiness and satisfaction with choosing Butler Insurance.

Acuity

Address 2800 South Taylor Drive PO Box 58 Sheboygan WI 53082-0058 United States General Inquiries: 920-458-9131 Billing: 800-242-7666 Claims: 800-242-7666 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Aegis General Insurance Company

Address 4507 N Front St Suite 200 Harrisburg PA 17110-1787 United States General Inquiries: 866-662-5752 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Allstate

Address P.O. Box 660598 Dallas TX 75266-0598 United States General Inquiries: 800-255-7828 Website Billing Website Claims Website

American Modern

Address P.O. Box 5323 Cincinnati OH 45201 United States General Inquiries: 800-543-2644 Billing: 800-543-2644 Claims: 800-375-2075 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Branch Insurance

Address 20 E Broad St Ste 1200 Columbus OH 43215 United States General Inquiries: 833-427-2624 Website Claims Website

Capitas Financial

Address 200 Coon Rapids Boulevard Suite 300 Minneapolis MN 55433 United States General Inquiries: 877-463-1234 Billing: 952-746-8059 Website

CNA

Address 333 S Wabash Ave Chicago IL 60604 United States General Inquiries: 800-262-2000 Billing: 877-276-7507 Claims: 800-262-2727 Website

Donegal Mutual Insurance

Address 1195 River Road P.O. Box 302 Marietta PA 17547-0302 United States General Inquiries: 800 877-0600 Claims: 800 877-9006 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Encompass Insurance

Address 3100 Sanders Rd Northbrook IL 60062 United States General Inquiries: 847-844-6100 Billing: 866-430-2916 Claims: 800-588-7400 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Foremost

Address PO Box 0915 Carol Stream IL 60132-0915 United States General Inquiries: 800-527-3905 Billing: 800-435-7764 Claims: 800-527-3907 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Grange

Address 671 S. High Street Columbus OH 43206 United States General Inquiries: 800-422-0550 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Hagerty

Address P.O. Box 1303 Traverse City MI 49685-1303 United States General Inquiries: 877-922-9701 Billing: 888-220-9565 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Hudson Insurance

General Inquiries: 212-978-2800 Claims: 866-546-3981 Website Claims Website

Indiana Farmers Insurance

Address 10 West 106th Street Indianapolis IN 46290 United States General Inquiries: 800-477-1660 Billing: 800-477-1660 Claims: 800-477-1660 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Liberty Mutual (Indiana)

Address 11611 N. Meridian St, Ste 105 Carmel IN 46032 United States General Inquiries: 800-379-2959 Billing: 800-225-8285 Claims: 800-225-2467 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Main Street America

Address 15490 101st Avenue North Maple Grove MN 55369 United States General Inquiries: 800-328-4628 Billing: 888-333-4014 Claims: 877-425-2467 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Markel

Address 4521 Highwoods Parkway Glen Allen VA 23060 United States General Inquiries: 800-431-1270 Website Billing Website Claims Website

National General Insurance

Address PO Box 3199 Winston-Salem NC 27102-3199 United States General Inquiries: 800-325-1088 Billing: 800-462-2123 Claims: 800-325-1088 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Nationwide

Address PO Box 742522 Cincinnati OH 45274-2522 United States General Inquiries: 877-669-6877 Billing: 877-262-0247 Claims: 800-421-3535 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Nationwide E&S Insurance

Address 18700 North Hayden Road Suite 1500 Scottsdale AZ 85255 United States General Inquiries: 800-423-7675 Claims: 800-423-7675 Website Claims Website

Philadelphia Insurance Companies

Address One Bala Plaza Suite 100 Bala Cynwyd PA 19004 United States General Inquiries: 877-438-7459 Billing: 877-438-7459 Claims: 800-765-9749 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Progressive

Address 6300 Wilson Mills Rd Mayfield Village OH 44143 United States General Inquiries: 888-671-4405 Billing: 888-671-4405 Claims: 800-776-4737 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Rockford Mutual Insurance Company

Address 527 Colman Center Dr PO Box 5626 Rockford IL 61125-5626 United States General Inquiries: 815-489-3210 Billing: 815-489-3178 Claims: 800-747-7642 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Safeco Insurance

Address P.O. Box 6476 Carol Stream IL 60197 United States General Inquiries: 800-332-3226 Billing: 888-723-3260 Claims: 800-332-3226 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Secura

Address 2401 South Memorial Drive PO Box 819 Appleton WI 54912-0819 United States General Inquiries: 800-558-3405 Billing: 800-830-9150 Claims: 800-318-2136 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Selective

Address 11711 North Meridian Street Suite 800 Carmel IN 46032 United States General Inquiries: 866-248-0850 Billing: 888-974-7400 Claims: 866-455-9969 Website Billing Website Claims Website

State Auto Insurance Companies

Address 518 East Broad St Columbus OH 43215 United States General Inquiries: 800-492-5246 Billing: 800-444-9950 x5118 Claims: 800-766-1853 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Stillwater Insurance Group

Address 5385 Hollister Ave Bldg 13 Santa Barbara CA 93111 United States General Inquiries: 855-712-4092 Claims: 800-220-1351 Website Billing Website Claims Website

The Hanover

Address PO Box 580045 Charlotte NC 28258-0045 United States General Inquiries: 800-922-8427 Billing: 800-922-8427 Claims: 800-628-0250 Website Billing Website Claims Website

The Hartford

Address One Hartford Plaza Hartford CT 6155 United States General Inquiries: 800-624-5578 Billing: 800-423-6789 Claims: 800-243-5860 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Travelers – Personal Lines

Address PO Box 660307 Dallas TX 75266-0307 United States General Inquiries: 866-336-2077 Billing: 800-842-5075 Claims: 800-252-4633 Website Billing Website Claims Website

United States Liability Group (USLI)

Address 1190 Devon Park Drive PO Box 6700 Wayne PA 19087 United States General Inquiries: 800-523-5545 Billing: 866-632-2003 Website Billing Website Claims Website

Universal Property

Address 1110 W Commericial Blvd Suite 300 Fort Lauderdale FL 33309 United States General Inquiries: 954-958-1200 Billing: 800-425-9113 Website Billing Website Claims Website

West Bend

Address 1900 S 18th Ave West Bend WI 53095 United States General Inquiries: 800-236-5010 Claims: 877-922-5246 Website Billing Website Claims Website